SInce I consider these the only REAL CDs these boys have ever put out. SO, that is why the recent CRAP isnt included! Give your opinion!

Master was Metallica at their peak....before the aliens abducted them and left their sucky dopplegangers behind!

What Pagan Said, hehe :D

That's easy......Ride the Lightening

okay this was tough for me... I loved Kill 'Em all as well.. but I thought that the sound was more polished and loved the harmonies in "Justice"

Ok, I voted for "And Justice for All" :)

I think this is the only one that I actually liked....

I think For Whom the Bell Tolls is about the heaviest song they ever recorded.

It´s no synthpop so they all suck...j/k :D

My entry into the fields of metal was (of course ;) ) the Black album. It took me a long time to decide, as I personally think that all their albums up to the Black one are great.

It was "Justice..."...great harmonies but still heavy as shit. ;)

*rubs his eyes* Wave?? What are you doing in here? I am glad to see you dumped that crappy synthpop and found out where the real music is....just kidding with ya buddy. :D

^5 to wave :)

That's a hard one. I picked Justice but I loved Puppets and Lightening as well. I think my favorite is Justice because of all the double bass. It sounds so damn awesome with my 12" Orions... :)

Okay.. Sal.. if I wasn't already in love with you.. I am now! ;) *insert big lick smile*

Master of Puppets. Great memories associated with that album. :)

KILL EM ALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL !!!!!!!!!!!!

That is my second choice Skyklad. :cool:

Justice is tied with Master??? *Not Man hangs his head in shame* Oh the humanity..... :p

Even though I no longer listen to Metallica because they don't seem to care about their fans. (All they care about is money and how they can shut down all the Napsters of the world!) Master Of Puppets and ...And Justice For All were my two fave albums.

I think master of puppets was the best album although I really liked And justice for all too. There was this instrumental on master of puppets that i really liked...but at this moment I can't remember what the name of it was. I'm sure you guys know which one i'm talking about. :)

That was hard. I can never decide which I like best, Justice, Lightning or Puppets. I voted for Puppets though.

Master!!!!

I agree... things after 'Justice' were crrrrap!! especially after the 'Black' CD

Close choice for me between Puppets and Ride The Lightning...

Actually, I consider the Black Album much better than their latest works. When I first heard the Black Album, I wasn't shocked - I already heard that they were slowing down from a reliable source. After a while, I thought it could be a good, positive direction for Metallica. Even though it wouldn't be my favorite hard metal, it still had some quality.

I liked the following songs from the black album:

Don't Tread On Me
Nothing Else Matters
Wherever I May Roam
Sad But True
Through The Never
The Struggle Within

Although they are all far from my favorite Metallica songs, they're way better than anything from either of the Load (of crap) albums.